Brad:
This chapter is a poem written by Omar Khayyám (1048-1131) called Rubáiyát; the poem consists of four line verses. Omar's lifestyle could be summed up in the phrase Wine, Women, and Song. Omar was also an astronomer and mathematician; some research suggests he was an early believer that the earth revolved around the sun. Lastly, he was a non-believer unlike the last chapter's author.
This chapter is a poem written by Omar Khayyám (1048-1131) called Rubáiyát; the poem consists of four line verses. Omar's lifestyle could be summed up in the phrase Wine, Women, and Song. Omar was also an astronomer and mathematician; some research suggests he was an early believer that the earth revolved around the sun. Lastly, he was a non-believer unlike the last chapter's author.
This particular author felt it hard to believe in a higher power that would reveal himself to some people and not to others; the part that bothered him most about this was the fact that those who were spoken to by god seemed to always use that knowledge to wield wealth and power for themselves. This too has been an issue for me and I understand is argued as a fault of organized religion and not necessarily the higher power itself.
One part of the poem that speaks to my feelings about god deal with believers (most, not all) talking about how great god is and heaven is going to be, and how wicked and unholy this world is now. To me, even if there is a god/heaven, why not make the life you live now heaven? If you are unhappy with your life, relationships, etc. why not change them? I mean if it weren’t for these books that are “god’s words” how many people will have divorced and be living a life that makes them happier? I think the happier a person is with the life they have, the more productive and kind a person they will be to those around them.
Something else mentioned in the poem is talking about how a believer’s self-righteousness is more sinful than the sins of a non-believer (non-violent sins like pleasure, enjoyment of food/drink, etc). While all believers I know would state they are not perfect and are not here to judge others, if asked “If you died at this very moment, would you go to heaven?”, most (if not all) would say “yes”. Is that not a form of judgment; albeit a positive judgment? If asked the same question of a non-believing friend of this believer, would in most/all cases that same believer say “no”? If people weren’t judging each other and their worthiness for heaven, why would anyone feel compelled to convert others?
Lastly, and I think most telling to me, is the part of the poem when the author talks about believers views of god and his love. If god is responsible for the earth and everything on it, why would god make grapes and then have his followers believing the consumption of the grapes (as wine) is a sin? The author feels that if god is going to get all the credit/praise for all good things on earth, he should also get the blame for all bad things. I know that believers will quote scripture to show why this view is inaccurate, but if you are going to quote scripture than the discussion around the existence of a god should allow for the connection between god and religion; I don’t feel the two can be mutually exclusive.
If someone continues to say god loves us, and yet he is allowed to test our faith/love in him without any expectation of that love/faith to be return to us when we would most like/need it (tragic events, etc) why continue to believe he exists and actually does love us? To me, if someone you knew treated you like god did: taking credit for all good things in your life, letting bad things happen to you without showing any concern, etc., you would ask yourself “Does this person actually love/care about me?” If god is an all-knowing/all-powerful being, why is it that it seems to be ok to expect more of one another than we are allowed to expect of god?
DJ:
I would have to agree that too often organized religion acts as though they have the keys to heaven. It is nonsense. And even if they did, the way they wield them is often in contradiction with the God they claim to follow. But as I argued in the last blog post, you have to draw that distinction. I think we kind of agree to kind of agree on that point.
As far as having heaven here on earth....that would be kind of self defeating to heaven. I get your argument, I am just saying, reason stands that it isn't possible on earth. As far as happiness, that is always going to be elusive. And impossible without "sadness". As to divorce, first, I am in no way advocating divorce. Let me just be clear on that. Where I would differ to those who say it is some unpardonable sin that guarantees you a life in hell begins with the belief that God hates ALL sin, and does not differentiate. From there I go to the argument of, sure, you can call it bearing false witness against God, or lying about what the church is, or any other "Sin" you want to wrap it up in, but what about the guy that lies a lot? What about the guy that cheated on his wife and got the other girl pregnant? What about murderers who have killed more than once? These guys get a pass but the person who got a divorce because they do what causes all those other sins and starts thinking the world revolves around them? It's the same sin, different face. Again, I don't think divorce is the best way to go, but I don't think lying is the way to go, I don't think greed is the way to go, and at the base of all those, I don't think making everything conform to the way I want it to go is the best way.....yet I do it. And so does everyone else. From the most "righteous" amongst us the most sinnerest of sinners.
To the conversation example, I don't believe the question even has to be asked. I think if someone does things a certain way for a reason, I think their actions have already stated where they stand. If I thought it was a free for all and I could do whatever I wanted without any fear of consequences, then why on earth would I not do these things? You don't even have to ask if I would disagree with the other person, obviously I do. Where "religious" or even "non religious" folks get it wrong is they think it is their business to know where someone stands. Why? Why do you care? There is really a God out there that told you it was your purpose in life to stick your nose in someone else's business and tell them what they should do? And to those that don't believe there is a God, what do you care why we believe there is a God? Does it have anything to do with you and your affairs? And I don't say that meanly, I mean seriously, what business is it of mine if you are an atheist or not? I think most people would rather just be left alone about it, let me believe what I believe, and if I have questions, I will come ask. If I see that your way is a little bit better, then I will inquire as to what you do differently than me and see if I agree with it. If not, I will just keep it to myself. And so on and so forth. As you stated in the last blog post, you think the right thing is doing unto others as they would do unto you, so do I.....so if we both feel the same about wanting to believe what we believe, then why would we even discuss it? (I know this would seem contradictory to a debate over the topics we are covering, but when two people kind of agree to "compare notes" we obviously agreed to discuss it, as opposed to me yelling at you or vice versa). I think if everyone acted like that, the world would be a much different place.
In regards to the grapes/wine, I accept your challenge joyfully! I am going to argue this strictly with reason. Why would God create grapes and then call drinking a sin (which He doesn't)? Why not argue "Why would God create hands and call murder by strangulation a sin?" Or "Why would God create water and call murder by drowning a sin?' And I don't say that mockingly, I'm just saying, spread it out a little and you have to arrive at the conclusion of, well, obviously there were some good intentions at some point.
And lastly, in regards to your last argument, why would you only ask God to intervene when you would most like it? Or when you most need it? I think that just falls back into the argument of wanting things my way. And that's not God's way. This argument also supposes that happiness is something that can be had at all times. I touched on it earlier, and I will expand here, but if you could be happy all the time, how would you know you are actually happy? If there is nothing to compare it against, then how does it exist? And you can't say, "well there would be different degrees of happiness" because then we would have to come up with names for these degrees of happiness and at some point you would want that full degree of happiness which is pretty much where we stand now. And I don't know what it is exactly God is supposed to do to not let bad stuff happen to us? Is he supposed to override our free will? Well that would just make him an Indian giver and a liar. And that isn't a God.
Brad:
I only want to make a response to the why believers and non-believers care why the other one believes the way that they do; I don’t care, until it gets shoved in my face. I think people who are gay, are genetically pre-disposed to be attracted to the same sex. Most (not all) people of faith would disagree with that, and some will actually lump gays in with pedophiles and those who practice bestiality. As someone who believes in evolution, there are studies that show there is homosexuality in different animal species, and clearly you can’t argue animals are choosing to be gay since they live their lives by instinct.
I think if you want to have your faith and you will allow me to have my non-faith, you are correct, life would be great. However, it seems that most people in the public arena, legislators, want to legislate morality. Whatever faith the legislator is, he/she tries to push that belief system into his/her policy. I don’t think someone has to ignore their belief system because others may disagree, but I do think when you govern multiple groups, there HAS to be compromise. If you think about what most believers don’t like and want to outlaw (abortion, gay marriage, etc.) doesn’t affect how they live their lives. If someone makes a mistake and has unprotected sex, and chooses to (in a responsible amount of time, before fetus is viable outside of the womb) have an abortion, how does that affect the believers life? Unless it is their child or spouse, then it doesn’t!
DJ:
I would concur about having someone else's views shoved in my face. That has always been my problem with the gay movement, is that the people that represent them the most (or so it would seem) are always up in someone's face telling them that they have to accept them. No, I don't. (For clarification I have nothing against gay people, do what you want, and just don't tell me what I have to do.) Just like they don't have to accept my views on God. There is no difference between them and Christians who pretty much put a bible two inches from your nose and say "you have to respect this!". Like there is no other option. I don't think anyone who approaches others this way is even owed a response, much less a dignified one.
I don't know that I would agree that people are genetically pre-disposed to be attracted to the same sex, I haven't seen concrete evidence on either side of the argument. From what I have seen in my own life though, I can't really say that everyone is born liking the opposite sex and then just choose to like the same sex. I can think of a couple guys I went to school with that as early as middle school you knew there was something a little "off" about them, and sure enough, they are gay this very day.. (Again, not calling gay people off, simply saying when you have 100 guys and only two of them like other dudes, there is obviously something "off" there.)
Regardless if I agree or disagree though, I think you have to stretch pretty far to lump them in with pedophiles or zoophilics. Obviously there is a difference between a man who sleeps with another man, and someone who would sleep with a child or with an animal. Sure, there are morons who lean on rhetoric and try to draw that conclusion, but you already know where I stand on them. To those that say, "well if we let same sex marriage go through, then how do we say no to these other things?" I think the argument they are trying to make goes to extremes in some cases but makes perfect sense in others. I would say most, not all are simply trying to maintain a standard. (side note, let's not blame every anti gay marriage perspectives on religion, some people just don’t like it). So if you do away with that long held standard, then you have to revisit other things. Why can't I have more than one wife? Why can't I marry a 14 year old girl (and then in turn if gay marriage is allowed, why not a 14 year old boy?). What do you base it on? If you demolish a standard, then you open up the floodgates. Not that I agree, just saying. I think people are comfortable with a standard that they can base their argument on (as silly as that standard may seem.).
Now, and this will have to serve as a response to your second point as well, where and why do Christians throw their hat in the ring? If you ask me, it is none of our business what America or the world does. None. I don't think we should even be in the argument......on any matters in America or the world. And you kind of touched on it with your last sentence/question. I'll just go further. My confusion and dismay with the church throwing its two cents in is that it ABSOLUTELY does not matter. If I am a Christian, and I know/think gay marriage is wrong, and the country I live in legalizes it, does that mean I am going to do it? If I live in a country that calls abortion ok am I going to say, yea, go ahead and kill the baby? Of course not! Followers of Christ are not called to be part of the world. And to anyone who disagrees with this, I would challenge you to go back and look at the time when God walked the earth in the person of Christ and show me one example, outside of telling us to pay taxes, where he even considered the notion of inserting himself into Roman politics. He never does. And while you can certainly make the case that Christian leaders have done so since after Christ’s death, I have to ask you....whom do you follow? Dr. King, Thomas Jefferson, Rick Warren, Pope Luke, Paul, John, Martin Luther, John Calvin or any other number of these leaders or do you follow Christ? The two are not agreeable. I don't even know why we vote, why we would run for any office or any other thing that you would consider "American". That's why there doesn't have to be compromise, at least as far as a Christian should be concerned Followers of Christ, if they are really trying to be "Christ like" should do like Christ and do what we believe to be right based on what Christ did. And I don't think He ever checked if what He was saying was ok with the Romans or even with the "church leaders" of the day.
Brad:
I personally think that there is more evidence that speaks to some sort of connection between homosexuality and genetics. I think, genetics play more of a role than nurture does. To me the evidence discovered in research over the last 14 years, is more evidence than I have seen for the existence of a higher power/god.
Comfort level is an excuse. People use to be comfortable owning other humans, not letting others marry who they want because they aren’t of the same race, etc. We got smart and stopped being comfortable with those items.
EVERYONE who wants to allow gay marriage, and those gays that want to get married are ALL talking about 2 (not 3 or 5) consenting ADULTS (over age 18 y-o). Most (nearly 90%) of pedophiles self-identify as HETEROSEXUAL. Most of that 90% is married to a woman and have kids. So it seems like heterosexuals are more of a danger to children than gays are ever going to be. Obviously there is NAMBLA, but I think gays and straights alike agree that group is Coo-Coo. If anyone is going to argue the B.S. “slippery slope” angle, they are just trying to outlaw what they don’t know; because outlawing it is easier than trying to understand it. I think if those people who are against gay marriage got to realize that they probably know or work with gay people, and that they very well may like these gay people, they are going to be much less likely to hateful defend an outdated concern. There are a lot of good economical benefits to allow gays to marry, lord knows the gays (I use that term affectionately) have a LOT of money ($2 TRILLION gay spending power by 2012). The money that would go into the economy on gay weddings alone would be astronomical.
As far as the area of politics, your thoughts on Christians not holding office, oddly I defend the people of faith on this one. I don’t think there is anything in scripture that implies they should stay above the fray on this one. Those who are believers or not, if you are running or holding office with the idea that you will not work for common ground and your only goal is to further your agenda at all cost no matter what; you are personally responsible for the shitty governments throughout this country/world. So I am perfectly fine with a person of faith holding office, as long as they realize that they also represent those people who believe differently than they do.
DJ:
I will admit it is hard for me to argue against same sex marriage, not for any of the reasons that you have listed above, but directly related to my second point. This will sound cold, but I simply don't care, because of who I am and who I believe in. It's kind of like abortion, or the death penalty or any other other "hot topic".....regardless of what the people of a given country decide for themselves, it has nothing to do with me. America says abortion is ok, I would never say it is ok or have anything to do with it. America says the death penalty is ok (in some states), I would never seek to have someone face death. America can say same sex marriage is ok, that doesn't mean I would say to a brother, oh, yea, go ahead and marry another dude. Now, I am not lumping same sex marriage in with abortion or the death penalty, simply drawing a parallel.
As to christians involving themselves in politics, I think if you would have to take Christ out of context to make the argument that christians should involve themselves in politics, be it holding office or even voting. Is there "scripture" that specifically states to not do so? Nope. Does anything about God's interaction with the Jews before Christ, then God walking the earth in the person of Christ, or even the letters from the apostles after his resurrection ever point to involving themselves in the politics of a given country? Not at all. For instance, why send Moses to Pharaoh? Why not just set up a JewPAC that worked to find common ground with Ramesses? Why have Christ die at the hands of the Romans (outside of the obvious need to fulfill prophecy)? Why not just organize all those that believed in him to write letters to Pilate begging for clemency? And why would Paul need to be murdered for his beliefs? Wouldn't it have served him (and others martyred for their faith) better to ingrain himself to the powers that be of the time and make it illegal to kill those that believed in the Christ? Again, the only time Christ ever addressed any "politics" was when he told the Jews to render unto Caesar what is Caesars. We have always been a people called apart, so for me, it's the equivalent of you visiting France for a year or two, knowing full well that you are coming back to America, but inserting yourself in their politics and trying to find a common ground. You wouldn't do that because that is not your home and those people are not your people. So it's not really your concern, and you wouldn't want your french equivalent doing the same. The same applies to christians, although on a much longer (hopefully) time frame.