Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Chapter One ....DJ (point)....Brad (counterpoint)

Justin:

I'll be frank, in reading the first chapter of "The Portable Atheist", I had to double check when the book was actually written. I was surprised to find that it was written in 2007. The reason is this, from the introduction, and the title itself, this book would seem to be something that would lend credence to an atheistic point of view. If this is how Hitchens intends to do so, I will be blunt, it will be very hard not to mock this book. I was tempted to ask Brad if we could just skip this chapter, because in my view, this particular section argues AGAINST atheism. But, that wouldn't be any fun, and would go against what we are trying to do.

The first problem this chapter would create for an atheist, is that the author of the poem isn't making the argument that there are no Gods, rather, part of his argument is, the Gods exist, but they didn't create the world and they don't interfere in it's daily workings. Obviously I would disagree with the argument that they didn't create the world, but that is neither here nor there in reference to these writings. The authors point is that atoms move in an infinite void, and so essentially what you see living isn't it's own being, but rather just a regrouping of atoms that would have come from another being. (Ex. Bull dies, atoms still exist, regroup in another bull, or a tree, or a fish, or....something). While you could certainly argue that to mean there are no Gods, again, the author never says that.

Secondly, Hitchens, in his introduction of the poem, gives us the history of it. Short version, it was written in 58 BC, and the theory (Atomism) was persecuted as heresy by the early Church, and so they burned all copies of the writing, one survived and that was translated several times, and the one Hitchens went with was almost destroyed by the Nazi bombardment of England in 1943. Hitchens then goes snide and says "if a religious book had survived so many vicissitudes, we can easily imagine what the faithful would say. But Luceritus (the author) teaches us to live without such piffle. " Agreeable and uncalled for all at the same time, sort of a "look at these simpletons" stereotyping of people who believe in God(s). Of course I would be remiss if I didn't point out that an atheist who uses the common atheist argument against those who live with such piffle are stuck in the dark ages when people could not explain what we know to be accepted science is trying to strengthen his case by having us read an outdated poem (58 BC) that pretty much flies in the face of accepted science. But then again, he would make an argument against there being any Gods by pointing to a text that never claims there are no Gods. So take that for what it is worth.

In short, this selection of text as an essential reading for a non believer is self defeating.


Brad:

I can see why Justin could find this first chapter counterproductive since Hitchens has been very outspoken about his disdain for belief in a higher power/religion. I started by looking at a list of the authors and trying to see why each author was included, and I think more important, is the order in which the book is organized. It appears (trying not to read ahead or out of order) that this book is fairly chronological; a way for Hitchens to show a history or evolution of non-believer thoughts. Justin made it clear that these thoughts expressed by the chapter author Lucretius aren't embraced by science now like they were 2100 years ago. Since this first author is prior to the birth of Jesus, I think to show everyone how far non-believer thought has come, and what sort of role science has played in that evolution, Hitchens starts with this author.

Even though this author wouldn't really be considered an atheist by today's definition, I still feel he speaks to points I find important for atheists; morality. I have heard believers say that you can't know right or wrong with god/religion (I am talking to you Steve Harvey), I bring up this point: Atheists who act in similar ways as christians/catholics etc (charitably, giving, non-material approach to life) I feel show a more genuine sense of morality because there is no ulterior motive for an atheist; no heaven to work towards. To atheists I know, heaven is on earth, make the absolute most of it. That doesn't mean do as you please; it means to live as true of a life as you can, and help those around you, period. While most of the believers I know, I believe, would still be the kind and generous people that they are; it can't really be proven that they would still live their lives that way if they were ever convinced there was no afterlife. I mean if you believe in an afterlife and that if you act a certain way and believe certain things you will get to experience this heavenly forever, it would be possible that you do/think/believe what you do to get this ultimate prize. I am not saying I believe that to be the case, but it would have to be acknowledged as possible that if someone stopped believing in god, they may not live the same pious life they did.


Justin:

I agree with Brad here, in doing some research, I too found that the book is indeed in chronological order. Hopefully Brad is correct and Hitchens will show the history of atheism. 

I would agree that it would be interesting to see how believers would act if they didn't think there was a reward for their good/pious actions in life. And I would agree that contrary to popular opinion, atheists aren't "evil" people insomuch that they don't do "good" things. Hitchens himself set up a charity called "Non-Believers For Aid" which at this moment is trying to help with the disaster in Haiti. And good for him, I think it is good that the world sees that you don't have to be a believer to do good things.

A couple points I would raise are these: A central tenet, of the Christian faith at least, is that works and deeds get you nowhere. Sure, there are people who think that doing all these good things make them righteous and earn them the ultimate prize, but they are wrong. If your works could get you into Heaven, then there is simply no need for Christ. There would be no need for Him to be the ultimate sacrifice replacing the sacrifices of the Jews to atone for their sins. God never would have had to come down in the person of Christ, he could have said, "Hey champ, throw some more change in the red bucket and I'll put a word in for you at the pearly gates.". But he did come down and that is what opens the gates, not any good thing anyone does. 

The second point I would raise is that if there were no God or Gods, then where do we get the concept of what is good and what is evil? If there is no God, then there is no absolute truth. If there is no absolute truth then there is no way to say "this is good and this is bad". What can you base it on if there is no God/Truth? Sure we might all say that murder is bad....but, if there is no truth, I can easily make the case that shooting someone in the head and taking their money is ok, because, well, I say it's ok. With no definite in life you could make no reasonable argument that it is wrong. Where is the measuring stick? Because alot of people think it's wrong? Because alot of people decided that taking someone else's life is wrong? What are they basing that on? Feelings? Psh, whatevs, I felt it was right.

If there is morality, then there is a truth. If there is a truth, then it has to come from somewhere. Christians and others say Christ, Buddhists would say Buddha, Muslims would say Muhammad via Allah and so on and so forth. 


Brad:

In response to Justin's two points:

1. Good Works don't get you into Heaven. Fine, that makes sense, if you buy into the christian (among other) faith(s).

2. Good/Evil. To answer If there is no absolute truth, then there is no way to say "this is good and this is bad". I fervently disagree. I think the golden rule is your basis for good/evil. If you wouldn't want it done to you, don't do it to someone else. It seems simple to me. I know there will be situations that come up that may not be so cut and dry, but that is why we have the legislature and court system.

Sunday, January 17, 2010

Introduction......DJ

As any introduction should, Hitchens lays his game plan for the entire book quite well. While some would hesitate at his lumping of Augustine, Luther, Calvin and Osama Bin Laden together, I see the point he is making and it is a good one. Religion, regardless of whatever "God" or "Holy Man" it aligns it self with, always has the potential for horrible acts. While you could say "Wait, we Christians don't strap ourselves with bombs and kill innocents", you would be ignoring the history of Christianity, or if you want to differentiate, Catholicism. Sure, it is not done now, but anytime there is an underlying attitude of "we are right, and you need to do things our way", you have the potential for these horrible acts. While we could certainly agree that there is a huge difference between killing innocent people while screaming Allah Akbar and say, voting for legislation that denies two gay people the right to get married, the undercurrent of exerting your will and your way on another because your God says that's how it should be is the same.

So there can be no arguing with Hitchens here, we agree, religion is a bad thing because of the potential for atrocities committed in the name of "God". Where Hitchens chooses to go with it on the other hand, I would not agree with that.

A common theme I run into when either reading or talking to someone who does not believe in one God, or many Gods or what have you, is their stance that since a certain religion has a violent past, their God should be outright dismissed. I have never understood this logic. Blaming a God, because at one point their people have committed atrocities against their fellow men is, in my head at least, baseless. Recently, one of the few doctors in the nation that would administer an abortion in the third trimester was murdered in the lobby of his church. Of course the murderer was part of a pro life network, or at least stated he was doing this in support of them, and of course pro lifers love to throw Gods name around as their reason for opposing abortion, ergo, it's God's fault this man was shot. I don't see how anyone, looking at the bible and what it says, could ever draw the conclusion that this man was doing God's work.

Think of it this way. Those of you that know me know that I am a pretty peaceful guy. I seriously am not a fan of violence. I don't like cramming my opinions down someones throat. I believe in the old "Live and let live" theory of life. While I might personally abhor the actions of someone else, I don't really do anything to get in their way. Do what you do. Personally, I am not a big fan of abortion and I think it's murder. Now, if someone were to go kill an abortion doctor and say the were doing it for me or doing it in my name, is there anyone who could reasonably say, oh, well, DJ is a bad person and his way of life is wrong because it causes people to murder? Throw out people who lack common sense, and the answer is a resounding no.

I feel the same way about God. People have used his name to and his laws as an excuse to commit atrocities, but how it is His fault, I just don't see it. You cannot look at His words and His actions and come to the conclusion that you are free to imply your will on others because God has called it sin.

Another common argument Hitchens leans on is "Why would a creator let bad things happen?". I always take this as "God isn't doing what I would do, so therefore he doesn't exist". There are a couple ways to look at this. A million ways probably, but I will keep it to a couple. Let's go with a couple instances from Genesis. For the purest example of where he REALLY could have stepped in but did not, let's look at Eve and the apple. (sidenote, I'm not having the argument of was it a literal apple or not. Or whether the story of Adam and Eve is literal. That can be tackled at a later time). There was but one thing that Adam and Eve were told not to do, and that was to eat from the tree of knowledge. We are told this led to the downfall of man. And God knew this would happen. So if God was an intervening God who wanted to control every single thing that happens in life to make sure everything is rainbows and unicorns and smiley faces dancing in the clouds, then why didn't he say "Hey, Eve, don't eat that!". Why, when Cain raised his hand to kill Able, didn't God step in and say "whoa champ, put the weapon down."?


The answer is obvious, God gave man kind freedom. He also set up rules (not laws, I am just talking "programming" of how the world turns if you will) that he himself plays by. You can argue that he should have said "hey man, sin is cool, there is no payment that needs to be made" but he didn't. He went so far as to enter the world and let himself be killed to cover the payment that he demanded for sin. To me that says alot.

Another time you hear this reasoning is when natural disasters occur. To me it is kind of a mute point, and I understand that what I am about to say will sound cold and heartless, but at it's base it's logic, so at least hear me out. We are guaranteed of one thing in life. Death. When natural disasters occur, people die. What exactly is God supposed to do? I mean, 1.2 million people or so die worldwide every year from car accidents. 260,000 or so of those will be children. The estimate of deaths related to the recent earthquake in Haiti ranges from 100,000-200,000. We throw our hands in the air to shake them at God and say "Why did you not stop this from happening?!?!?!?!!" but when is the last time you went out to shake your hands at God and say "Why did you let people drive today?!?!?!?!?" I look at the reactions to hurricanes where people can't believe all the destruction and once again shake their fists at God...of course I would make the argument of "why live in a place where you are pretty much guaranteed hurricanes which are destructive in nature and expect anything less?" Same thing with tornadoes. Same thing with typhoons or anything else. You have a God that says focus on today but because we choose to disregard that and think of life as some 80 year guarantee, this is somehow His fault or at the very least he should have done something. For me, that just doesn't hold water.

A close cousin to this argument is, "Why does the creator allow suffering?". I will say this. People choose to suffer. Be it oppression, be it drought, be it whatever, these things can be handled by acting, but I find that most choose to wait. I do not see how God can be blamed for this either. It is the equivalent of living somewhere where water runs dry, animals no longer roam, and vegetation dies and sitting there waiting for it to come back as opposed to going and finding a place where those things exist. God cannot be blamed for inaction on the part of man.

The last thing I will touch on from the introduction (honestly, I could d0 150,000 words on it alone, but I think we will be able to get more specific as the book goes on), and I know Brad kind of touched on it, is the debate on the divinity of Jesus Christ. While I agree with Brad that the Bible was written by humans with human agendas, I still find that there is evidence that Jesus did in fact claim to be God and there is too much evidence that can't simply be dismissed as the result of a human agenda.

(Quick tangent/full disclosure....I do not look at the Bible as a "spiritual" book if you will. When I read it, I look at it as a historical text, much like one might look any other history book. Quite frankly, you could get rid of everything after Acts, maybe Hebrews, and I would have no problem with that. But just because it is not "spiritual" does not mean it should be discounted. Just so everyone knows where I am coming from.)

I think to simply dismiss Jesus and try to compare him to the Tooth Fairy or Santa Claus (as Hitchens does) is really rather juvenile and shows an unwillingness to tackle the subject. Hitchens goes on to either show that A. he is intentionally being misleading by saying Jesus never claimed to be God or that B. he has simply decided to not even look to see if Jesus claimed to be God. Either way you look at it, he is wrong. To say that Jesus never claimed that is simply untrue. When being questioned by the Jewish leaders of the time he was asked "You are not yet fifty years old, and you have seen Abraham?" To which he replied "Before Abraham was born, I am." We then see that they picked up stones to throw at him, but he hid and then exited the temple.

I AM, is one of the many names of God. He used it in instructing Moses how to reply when asked who sent him. The Jews of course realized this, and in accordance with law, they tried to stone him. While there are many other instances where he claimed to be God, I am not going to go through every single one. For more examples, grab a bible, first four chapters of the New Testament.

To those who would dismiss these as silly old wives tales or the ignorance of a less advanced people or just hokey bible stories that have no basis, I end with this.

People sometimes act as though they view the historical stories of Jesus as something that happened on a stage with only main players involved. This is not a good way to look at it. The Jews of old, as they are today, were a people. The actions of Jesus were not performed in shadows or in hiding, but they were performed in public, where they would have been seen. Why does this matter? Quite simply, if the things that the bible says happened didn't happen, there would be many people when hearing these stories verbally or reading them could go to other people if they did not see it themselves and say "did this really happen"? Kind of like if I read a story that claimed Brett Farve threw a ball 500 yards but I didn't see it, I could track someone down that had and say "did this really happen?" and they could either confirm or refute it. When reading these stories, one has to keep in mind that there were witnesses upon witnesses that could have, and would have been quite happy to point out, that these things did not happen.

Furthermore, one cannot take away from just how revolutionary Jesus would have been in this time. While it would seem Christians of today want to wrap it up with a ribbon and make it a happy story that ends with Jesus buying the world a coke, it just isn't so. It would be akin to someone coming down, claiming to be God, and then telling Catholics "Hey, your candles, your rosaries, your Hail Mary's, your Our Fathers, your kneeling, your standing, your putting a cross on your head with ashes, your singing of certain psalms, your baptism, your communion, your saints, your popes, your customs and clothes......all wrong, all unnecessary, and will lead you to death. Chuck everything you have been taught, here is the truth." At this point, you could probably write him off. But then if that man were to die, and be risen from death, and then show himself to the very same people.......revolutionary doesn't even seem to do it justice.

While you could say, "well that is all well and good, but you still only have this in one book so therefore there is no corroborative evidence" you would be incorrect. A historian of the time, Josephus, mentions Jesus in his writings of history, as do several others. Granted, they do not make a big deal of it, but again, it was a total different time. They really wouldn't have cared. The Jews were a rag tag bunch, and to compare today's "state acknowledgement of religion" model to the way things were back then, it cannot be done. If you just read the bible, then yes, it seems like a huge deal (and it was....to Jews) but this was a history of a people for a people. To compare it to today, you would have to imagine that the church has absolutely no say in anything, they are totally ignored, Christians largely keep to themselves, are not involved in the politics of America, they are just largely unknown. Since they would seemingly not be intertwined in the workings of Amercia and would just be a group of people, those that write American history MIGHT mention them, but probably not give it much play because of how inconsequential to America they are. But that does not mean anything that happens amongst them didn't happen, and even a historical head nod to their existence and the huge challenge/change to their social structure would obviously be taken as external confirmation. You could then in turn look at THEIR history and go from there.

So again, I agree with Brad, there is certainly the possibility of agendas taking over the writing of the bible, which is why I am always suspect of just taking it as an authoritative text on what one can or cannot do (religion), but there is simply too much evidence that could not reasonably be affected by an agenda that points to the fact that Christ indeed lived, died, and rose again.

Saturday, January 16, 2010

Introduction.......Brad

I want to start by saying, like Justin, I am in no way trying to convert, or convince anyone on this blog.  My only goal is to give people a look at what a nonbeliever looks like; by that I mean to show people that nonbelievers are not immoral, self-centered, and careless people.

So the intro of this book gives us a glimpse into Mr. Hitchens' worldview.  If anyone has read any of his works (God is Not Great, God: The Failed Hypothesis), you will know he does not mince his words.  While the introduction of this book does speak of existence/non-existence of a god/intervening higher power, there was a lot of talk about religions connection/interpretation of what is god.  In my posts I will attempt to keep the discussion on god independent of religion; where possible.  The book being a collection of works by many authors, there should be plenty to discuss outside of what was conveyed by Hitchens himself in the introduction. I found a lot in the introduction I could discuss, but I just want to highlight a couple of the things that I know have crossed my mind before or I have heard discussed by others.

The one that jumps out at me first is looking at believers being Atheists; by that meaning that believers (typically) believe in just one god and (usually) don't give any thought to the god of other religions.  The people who do identify as Atheist just take it one god further.

The second point, this one usually starts the verbal insults thrown my way (for the record, never by DJ), is that even though Jesus of Nazareth was a living person, there isn't really verifiable proof that he was in fact the son of (the christian) god.  There is the christian bible, but that was written by humans. I know, I know, "inspired by god", but still written by humans who could have their own agendas.  I think it is reasonable to believe that someone in power, trying to control the actions of those they rule, would hope/want for scripture to be on their side, so to speak.  If anyone does a historical study of where the King James bible came from and what form it started in, you can see where there is room for things to have been changed by humans since the beginning version of  bound scripture (of many faiths, not just the christian faith).

As a closing point I just want to make it clear that while I have railed against organized religion in the past, I have no intentions on making this about why I think religion hurts society (unless it is pertinent to the current chapter/discussion).  I also will not "pick on" the christian faith; I mention it most often because it is the religion I practiced when I was a believer, and therefore the one I feel I understand the most.

I will wait to post my thoughts on Chapter One of the book until DJ has had a chance to post his thoughts on the Introduction.  Please feel free to comment on this post in the meantime.

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

The Book is..........The Portable Atheist by Christopher Hitchens

To make sure I am not making an opinion on the book before either of us have started reading, I will always post the Product Description from Amazon.com.




From the #1 New York Times best-selling author of God Is Not Great, a provocative and entertaining guided tour of atheist and agnostic thought through the ages--with never-before-published pieces by Salman Rushdie, Ian McEwan, and Ayaan Hirsi Ali.

Christopher Hitchens continues to make the case for a splendidly godless universe in this first-ever gathering of the influential voices--past and present--that have shaped his side of the current (and raging) God/no-god debate. With Hitchens as your erudite and witty guide, you'll be led through a wealth of philosophy, literature, and scientific inquiry, including generous portions of the words of Lucretius, Benedict de Spinoza, Charles Darwin, Karl Marx, Mark Twain, George Eliot, Bertrand Russell, Emma Goldman, H. L. Mencken, Albert Einstein, Daniel Dennett, Sam Harris, Richard Dawkins, and many others well-known and lesser known. And they're all set in context and commented upon as only Christopher Hitchens--"political and literary journalist extraordinaire" (Los Angeles Times)--can.

Atheist? Believer? Uncertain? No matter: The Portable Atheist will speak to you and engage you every step of the way.

Sunday, January 10, 2010

A little about the authors.....Justin (DJ)

I had two new years resolutions this year. One was to not spend money on Sundays (long story) the other was to focus my usual blog strictly on religion/God and what is real and what is not. Over the course of the last year or so, as Brad mentioned, we have had the opportunity to spar over various subjects, usually politics, but God/religion a couple times as well. And I agree, they have been civil and enlightening. When Brad brought up the idea of reading different books on atheism/religion and such, it hit me that instead of a blog by me on God and religion, it might be more interesting for two people from two different sides of the spectrum offering their take in a "debate" forum.

I, like Brad, found myself disillusioned with the church around 25 or so due to hypocrisy for lack of a better word. I had started souring on some of the leadership, seeing many things that did not add up in my head. I won't rake these people over the coals, after all, they are only human....but at the same time, I could see their actions causing someone to look elsewhere. While I haven't gone hiking through some Cambodian jungle or anything like that, I decided to "start over" if you will and disregard everything I had been taught. And after 8 or so years now of looking at it with fresh eyes, I still believe in God. And so that is where I will be coming from.

I look forward to a spirited debate, and that would be my only "goal" with this discussion/blog. I don't want to convert Brad, or anyone else reading this for that matter. I don't want to shout anyone down, or tell anyone they are dumb for what they believe or that they are going to hell. I think as you read this you will see there is a difference between what God is, and what his people say he is. At least in my opinion. And as we wouldn't yell/scream/degrade others when discussing two peoples opinion as to who has a better burger, Burger King or McDonalds, I would hope that the authors and any others who contribute to the dialogue would act in the same manner.

Let the good times roll!

Thursday, January 7, 2010

A little about the authors....Brad

My name is Brad; 30-something male living in the (sometimes) great state of Indiana.

You may ask yourself, WTF!?!  Why would anyone/two people decide to devote an entire blog to this discussion?  I would think at some point during this experiment in civility, Justin and I will both ask ourselves that same question.  To be honest, it is a discussion we have had on and off for more than a of year.  Even though we have different opinions on this subject (and others which I assume/hope we will cover in the future), I have great respect for the way Justin carries himself, and how he responds to those who's opinions are different than his own.

For those who may be reading this who may not know Justin or I, I am the non-believer in this discussion.  I haven't always been a nonbeliever, but came about finally identifying as an Atheist at about 25 years of age.  Prior to that I was a church-going Christian.  The more I started to study the King James bible, the more I was unsure about what I truly believed.  When I had questions, I would seek out the opinions of those I respect, and that were well respected in the (lost count) 5+ churches I have attended in my life.  Some questions were answered with quotes from Scripture, others ignored.  Along the way I became more and more disillusioned by not only organized religion, but the thought of a higher power/god too.

Well enough about me; I will let Justin tell you a little about himself, and then I will post a quick note about the first book we will be discussing.

What to Expect

Justin and I are going to debate about the existance of god/higher power; CIVIL debate. We know there are strong feelings about this, but we ask that all comments be respectful. We don't expect everyone to agree with either one of us, but we do expect to make people think. The discussion will be based on Justin and I reading chapters from the same book (some by atheists and others by believers of different faiths). This should be entertaining. Hope you enjoy!