I'll be frank, in reading the first chapter of "The Portable Atheist", I had to double check when the book was actually written. I was surprised to find that it was written in 2007. The reason is this, from the introduction, and the title itself, this book would seem to be something that would lend credence to an atheistic point of view. If this is how Hitchens intends to do so, I will be blunt, it will be very hard not to mock this book. I was tempted to ask Brad if we could just skip this chapter, because in my view, this particular section argues AGAINST atheism. But, that wouldn't be any fun, and would go against what we are trying to do.
The first problem this chapter would create for an atheist, is that the author of the poem isn't making the argument that there are no Gods, rather, part of his argument is, the Gods exist, but they didn't create the world and they don't interfere in it's daily workings. Obviously I would disagree with the argument that they didn't create the world, but that is neither here nor there in reference to these writings. The authors point is that atoms move in an infinite void, and so essentially what you see living isn't it's own being, but rather just a regrouping of atoms that would have come from another being. (Ex. Bull dies, atoms still exist, regroup in another bull, or a tree, or a fish, or....something). While you could certainly argue that to mean there are no Gods, again, the author never says that.
Secondly, Hitchens, in his introduction of the poem, gives us the history of it. Short version, it was written in 58 BC, and the theory (Atomism) was persecuted as heresy by the early Church, and so they burned all copies of the writing, one survived and that was translated several times, and the one Hitchens went with was almost destroyed by the Nazi bombardment of England in 1943. Hitchens then goes snide and says "if a religious book had survived so many vicissitudes, we can easily imagine what the faithful would say. But Luceritus (the author) teaches us to live without such piffle. " Agreeable and uncalled for all at the same time, sort of a "look at these simpletons" stereotyping of people who believe in God(s). Of course I would be remiss if I didn't point out that an atheist who uses the common atheist argument against those who live with such piffle are stuck in the dark ages when people could not explain what we know to be accepted science is trying to strengthen his case by having us read an outdated poem (58 BC) that pretty much flies in the face of accepted science. But then again, he would make an argument against there being any Gods by pointing to a text that never claims there are no Gods. So take that for what it is worth.
In short, this selection of text as an essential reading for a non believer is self defeating.
Brad:
I can see why Justin could find this first chapter counterproductive since Hitchens has been very outspoken about his disdain for belief in a higher power/religion. I started by looking at a list of the authors and trying to see why each author was included, and I think more important, is the order in which the book is organized. It appears (trying not to read ahead or out of order) that this book is fairly chronological; a way for Hitchens to show a history or evolution of non-believer thoughts. Justin made it clear that these thoughts expressed by the chapter author Lucretius aren't embraced by science now like they were 2100 years ago. Since this first author is prior to the birth of Jesus, I think to show everyone how far non-believer thought has come, and what sort of role science has played in that evolution, Hitchens starts with this author.
Even though this author wouldn't really be considered an atheist by today's definition, I still feel he speaks to points I find important for atheists; morality. I have heard believers say that you can't know right or wrong with god/religion (I am talking to you Steve Harvey), I bring up this point: Atheists who act in similar ways as christians/catholics etc (charitably, giving, non-material approach to life) I feel show a more genuine sense of morality because there is no ulterior motive for an atheist; no heaven to work towards. To atheists I know, heaven is on earth, make the absolute most of it. That doesn't mean do as you please; it means to live as true of a life as you can, and help those around you, period. While most of the believers I know, I believe, would still be the kind and generous people that they are; it can't really be proven that they would still live their lives that way if they were ever convinced there was no afterlife. I mean if you believe in an afterlife and that if you act a certain way and believe certain things you will get to experience this heavenly forever, it would be possible that you do/think/believe what you do to get this ultimate prize. I am not saying I believe that to be the case, but it would have to be acknowledged as possible that if someone stopped believing in god, they may not live the same pious life they did.
Justin:
I agree with Brad here, in doing some research, I too found that the book is indeed in chronological order. Hopefully Brad is correct and Hitchens will show the history of atheism.
I would agree that it would be interesting to see how believers would act if they didn't think there was a reward for their good/pious actions in life. And I would agree that contrary to popular opinion, atheists aren't "evil" people insomuch that they don't do "good" things. Hitchens himself set up a charity called "Non-Believers For Aid" which at this moment is trying to help with the disaster in Haiti. And good for him, I think it is good that the world sees that you don't have to be a believer to do good things.
A couple points I would raise are these: A central tenet, of the Christian faith at least, is that works and deeds get you nowhere. Sure, there are people who think that doing all these good things make them righteous and earn them the ultimate prize, but they are wrong. If your works could get you into Heaven, then there is simply no need for Christ. There would be no need for Him to be the ultimate sacrifice replacing the sacrifices of the Jews to atone for their sins. God never would have had to come down in the person of Christ, he could have said, "Hey champ, throw some more change in the red bucket and I'll put a word in for you at the pearly gates.". But he did come down and that is what opens the gates, not any good thing anyone does.
The second point I would raise is that if there were no God or Gods, then where do we get the concept of what is good and what is evil? If there is no God, then there is no absolute truth. If there is no absolute truth then there is no way to say "this is good and this is bad". What can you base it on if there is no God/Truth? Sure we might all say that murder is bad....but, if there is no truth, I can easily make the case that shooting someone in the head and taking their money is ok, because, well, I say it's ok. With no definite in life you could make no reasonable argument that it is wrong. Where is the measuring stick? Because alot of people think it's wrong? Because alot of people decided that taking someone else's life is wrong? What are they basing that on? Feelings? Psh, whatevs, I felt it was right.
If there is morality, then there is a truth. If there is a truth, then it has to come from somewhere. Christians and others say Christ, Buddhists would say Buddha, Muslims would say Muhammad via Allah and so on and so forth.
Brad:
In response to Justin's two points:
1. Good Works don't get you into Heaven. Fine, that makes sense, if you buy into the christian (among other) faith(s).
2. Good/Evil. To answer If there is no absolute truth, then there is no way to say "this is good and this is bad". I fervently disagree. I think the golden rule is your basis for good/evil. If you wouldn't want it done to you, don't do it to someone else. It seems simple to me. I know there will be situations that come up that may not be so cut and dry, but that is why we have the legislature and court system.