I want to start by saying, like Justin, I am in no way trying to convert, or convince anyone on this blog. My only goal is to give people a look at what a nonbeliever looks like; by that I mean to show people that nonbelievers are not immoral, self-centered, and careless people.
So the intro of this book gives us a glimpse into Mr. Hitchens' worldview. If anyone has read any of his works (God is Not Great, God: The Failed Hypothesis), you will know he does not mince his words. While the introduction of this book does speak of existence/non-existence of a god/intervening higher power, there was a lot of talk about religions connection/interpretation of what is god. In my posts I will attempt to keep the discussion on god independent of religion; where possible. The book being a collection of works by many authors, there should be plenty to discuss outside of what was conveyed by Hitchens himself in the introduction. I found a lot in the introduction I could discuss, but I just want to highlight a couple of the things that I know have crossed my mind before or I have heard discussed by others.
The one that jumps out at me first is looking at believers being Atheists; by that meaning that believers (typically) believe in just one god and (usually) don't give any thought to the god of other religions. The people who do identify as Atheist just take it one god further.
The second point, this one usually starts the verbal insults thrown my way (for the record, never by DJ), is that even though Jesus of Nazareth was a living person, there isn't really verifiable proof that he was in fact the son of (the christian) god. There is the christian bible, but that was written by humans. I know, I know, "inspired by god", but still written by humans who could have their own agendas. I think it is reasonable to believe that someone in power, trying to control the actions of those they rule, would hope/want for scripture to be on their side, so to speak. If anyone does a historical study of where the King James bible came from and what form it started in, you can see where there is room for things to have been changed by humans since the beginning version of bound scripture (of many faiths, not just the christian faith).
As a closing point I just want to make it clear that while I have railed against organized religion in the past, I have no intentions on making this about why I think religion hurts society (unless it is pertinent to the current chapter/discussion). I also will not "pick on" the christian faith; I mention it most often because it is the religion I practiced when I was a believer, and therefore the one I feel I understand the most.
I will wait to post my thoughts on Chapter One of the book until DJ has had a chance to post his thoughts on the Introduction. Please feel free to comment on this post in the meantime.
First off, totally digging the blog, guys. Great concept and execution. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDeleteBrad, can you elaborate on your comment about people who identify as Atheist taking it "one god further"?
Since believers only (typically) believe in just one (of the many out there) gods. So Atheists, just believe in one less god than believers do. I am sure I made that as clear as mud. :)
ReplyDelete