DJ
Thomas Hobbes (5 April 1588 – 4 December 1679), in some older texts Thomas Hobbs of Malmsbury, was an English philosopher, remembered today for his work on political philosophy. His 1651 book Leviathan established the foundation for most of Western political philosophy from the perspective of social contract theory.
Hobbes also contributed to a diverse array of fields, including history, geometry, physics of gases, theology, ethics, general philosophy, and political science. His account of human nature as self-interested cooperation has proved to be an enduring theory in the field of philosophical anthropology. He was one of the main philosophers who founded materialism. (From his wikipedia page.)
Also, a fun fact before we delve into more serious matters, the characters in the old comic "Calvin and Hobbes" were named after John Calvin and Thomas Hobbes.
In the introduction to the 3rd chapter of Christopher Hitchens book "The Portable Atheist", which is covering an excerpt (Of Religion) from Thomas Hobbes book "Leviathan", Hitchens assumes that which is not supported by the text, nor by the history of Thomas Hobbes himself. Hitchens claims that Hobbes "...took great care to make formal professions of loyalty to the established Church but found ways in his writing to throw doubt on faith" I will get to what I believe to be a erroneous reading of the selected text below, but would like to further the history that Hitchens starts where he states "The heresy-hunters were probably shrewd, if literal-minded, to threaten him with a trial by Parliament on charges of atheism in 1666". This is true, a bill was passed that was aimed squarely at "Leviathan", but Hitchens leaves out what came of this. The consequence of the book was that he was not allowed to publish anything in England on subjects related to human conduct. Furthermore, Hobbes actually studied the law of heresy and found that the only heresy was to oppose the Nicene Creed which neither Hobbes, nor his book "Leviathan" opposed. The lack of any consequences for this assumption would lead me to believe that this was true.
Hitchens ends his introduction to the twelfth chapter of "Leviathan" with "Hobbes ridicules religion by supposedly defending true faith against paganism". If one considers "true faith" the belief in a religion, then Hitchens has a point. But as Hobbes shows in the very chapter that Hitchens has selected, there is a difference, and very much so.
Hobbes starts this chapter by discussing the seed of religion that exists only in man. The seed being mans wonder as to what causes their own good and evil fortune, that man sees anything with a beginning also had a cause, and that when man cannot assure himself the true causes of things (evil or good) he either supposes what causes it or trusts his fellow man that he considers wiser than himself. He sums up the first two as the causes of anxiety or fear. Here, I agree with him, men have always, and will always, feared what they do not understand. And in turn, out of this fear Hobbes states "And therefore when there is nothing to be seen, there is nothing to accuse, either or their good, or evil fortune, but some power, or agent invisible: in which sense perhaps it was, that some of the old poets said, that the gods were at first created by human fear: which spoken of the gods, that is to say, of the many gods of the Gentiles, is very true" Essentially, and he delves more into detail later, that the Gentiles had many gods to explain away all that they fear.
As he does throughout the chapter, he then "supposedly" defends the true faith against this paganism. His defense here is essentially that those who do not fear, search out why all things happen, and in understanding cause and effect "shall at last come to this, that there must be, as even the heathen philosophers confessed, one first mover; that is, a first and an eternal cause of all things; which is that which men mean by the name of God".
Returning to the book, Hobbes then shows what men have done with these "seeds" of religion. He here separates leaders of the kingdoms of the world and leaders of the kingdom of God. Showing that both use this seed to sow in those who turn to these leaders an aptness for "obedience, laws, peace, charity, and civil society." in relation to their given kingdoms. Calling one human politics and the other divine politics, which is a way of saying "here is how you subject yourself to your given king." He then goes through many, many examples of the various gods created to explain away natural causes. He sums up this "roll call" of gods by correctly pointing out that the Romans, in their conquering of the greater part of the known world had no problem accepting any religion "unless it had something in it, that could not consist with their civil government" and points out that the only religion that was forbidden was that of the Jews "who, being the peculiar kingdom of God, thought it unlawful to acknowledge subjection to any mortal king or state whatsoever." In short, they did not care how many gods you believed in, so long as those gods did not get in the way of their rule.
From here, Hobbes goes on to again, "supposedly", defend true faith against religion. He walks us through the separation of human politics and divine politics (natural versus supernatural) and essentially points out that for judgment of what is going on....natural things require natural signs and supernatural things require supernatural signs such as miracles and prophecy proven true. He deduces correctly that with a lack of supernatural signs faith weakens and points to the bible for examples. He speaks of the children of Israel, having been freed from the Egyptians turning to a golden calf, when Moses was away from them but 40 days. And then he remarks on the children of Israel, after Moses, Aaron and Joshua's generation were no more, turning to serve Baal. He then shows where injustice by those who were chosen to judge the children of Israel caused them to cry out for a human king, therefore deposing of God. Then he carries it up to his current day showing how the failing of virtues in the pastors of various churches (both protestant and catholic) have caused men to to lose their faith.
Here is where I would disagree with Hitchens. At least in regards to this being a basis for atheism. If belief in God is indeed a submitting to the laws and teachings of man and their opinion as to how we should act in the kingdom of God, then I would have to say that I am an atheist as well. Hobbes in no way says God is religion, he shows that religion are the rules that man set up in the absence of some verifiable proof to eyes alone. Where the supernatural is seen (miracles or prophecy) man cannot be led astray because they see it. There is no need to pursue it because it is in front of them. Generations following though, not seeing with their own eyes, but left with nothing but an account from men they do not know can do one of two things.....live by faith, or turn to other men they consider wiser than themselves who say 'here is God". Hobbes points this out with the Israelites building a golden calf, or turning to serve Baal. That is not proof that there is no God, it is simply proof that these people lacked faith. We see this in our generation with churches. While they may dress themselves up and say "here is God" that does not mean they are God. Where are their miracles, where is their prophecy? Where is this supernatural that is God? Where is their justice? Where is their virtue? However, instead of following it through and pursuing it, Hitchens says I choose to believe there is no god. However, this basis is faulty by scientific measures, and therefore we can call Hitchens a hypocrite, as he has just set up another religion, in so much as he refuses to pursue understanding.
Brad
I have to agree with DJ; Hitchens reaches when stating that Hobbes “ridicules religion.” I actually think that Hobbes is speaking about the unquestioning living of one’s life according to laws and morals set by others (be it religious or governmental entities). We all understand that there are going to be some things that we can all agree on; don’t steal each other’s stuff, don’t kill each other, etc. Everything else; relationships, consumption of drugs and alcohol, there is room and reason to question any authority.
The “seeds” of control that Hobbes mentions here; one from a manmade (governmental) prospective and another spiritual (higher power) prospective, just go to show how each walk (and usually cross) that fine line between control for control’s sake and the control for the “greater/common good”. The more I read this chapter, the more religion struck me as having a lot in common with a socialist or communist government. Just look how both the church and socialist/communist government want to control how much of your own money you keep, who you can/cannot marry, when and how many children you can/should have, so on and so on.
Fear - organized religion and governments (any kind of government) use it to their advantage. If you don’t have facts or evidence on your side, use fear. To me, fear of the unknown is the only reason religion or the belief in a higher power even exists. However, once a person gets over that fear, they can start to live a life on their own terms. That last sentence doesn’t mean I think you shouldn’t have to think about or be responsible for your actions and how they may injury others around you. I think if you are living a life that doesn’t injury (mentally/emotionally/physically) those around you, then no government or church should have a right to control your actions/thoughts/words.
Another point I agree with DJ on is the doubt/certainty of those on both sides of this god/no god discussion. While I feel the bible has flaws, and evolution isn’t without its holes, I do feel there is a difference in the arguments of believers vs. non-believers. For one, science is (and should always) be questioned. Most atheists (especially those in the sciences) will admit there is no way to know for sure that there is no higher power, and that is why scientific theories are continually tested. A good scientist approaches a hypothesis with the intent of trying to disprove it. I don’t think the same thing can be said of those who cite the bible, and the bible only, in the arguments for why there is a higher power. The reason religion “works” is because of the overall feel that what believers are told about god/faith/etc is above reproach. I have always felt (even when I was a Christian) that the more you are told not to question something, the more you should. If I didn’t believe that way, I might still believe in a god.
If people are ever going to get along (as much as is possible), everyone needs to stop walking around like they have all the answers – as if there isn’t something they couldn’t learn from someone who believes differently than they do.
DJ
I completely agree that religion is the identical twin of a socialist or communist government. Any government for that matter. I also think it warrants mentioning that when religion was THE government, more innocent people died than at any other period in life. When the Catholic Church ruled the world, they shed more innocent blood than any kingdom before it, and any kingdom after it. We consider Hitler one of the most evil people to have ever graced the face of the planet earth, but even if you were to take a conservative estimate of how many people died at the hand of the pope (several, actually), Hitler killed but a tenth of what they killed. Not giving a free pass to Hitler, simply pointing out that the poster boy for all things wrong had a long way to go to catch them. However, I still have to point out that the Catholic Church, or any church for that matter is not God. They may say they are, but a lot of people claim to be that which the are not. That aside, I think the parallel of the two can go further. I look at a country like America, and I see a place that started out pretty free. Sure there were some common laws, but these were common sense laws, more a rebuke of rules and regulations than a "hey, you do this!". Everything about them are things you would take to be a basic human right. These days? Out of fear, Americans ask and ask and ask and ask and ASK for more rules. As if laws could save us.
I see the church of today in the same light. I know actually reading the bible is cliche these days, but you have Christ wrapping up every single law that was ever handed to the Jews with "Do unto others as you would expect them to do unto you". That was it, seems basic enough, common sense if you will. But these days, it's not good enough. If it were, you would have no need for a church. You would have no need for all the things that are "expected" of a good christian. Jesus words weren't good enough, we need laws that tell us how to act. Again, as if laws could save us.
I have to agree and disagree to the fear point though. Obviously I believe fear leads to religion, but I would disagree that fear leads to the belief in a higher power. Common sense says to me that there is a God. I'll delve more into this later in this response, but I have never seen something appear from nothing. History also says to me there is a God. The bible is just not a spiritual book, but it is also a history book. Events that are spelled out in it can be verified through various studies that we would accept for other historical events, I can take it as valid historically. Does it have holes? Sure. Do they effect the overall story being told by many different people over a long period of time? Not really. Read enough history books about any given event, or any other person and you will see disagreements here and disagreements there, but at the end of the day, you don't write any of them off because they disagreed over a name of a town or the number of people at a event. To use a current example, there will be thousands of books written about Barack Obama. I think there will be contradictions here and there, but I bet if we could go into the future, and read them all, we would end up saying, "eh, yea, you got some stuff off here and there, but the general consensus of all these books is an accurate portrait of who he was." I feel a meandering ramble coming on, so I am going to stop there. My basic point is there is no fear in either of those reasoning's and most would use both of those to come to a belief that would be considered "well thought out". (Side note: Oddly enough, it is my belief in the historical records of that book that makes me identical to you. Forgive me if I am reading this wrong, but it sounds like you just said a life without fear leads to "do unto others as you would expect them to do to you". And I couldn't agree more.)
As to the last point, I have to agree. Again, though, from a different perspective. I do not understand why the church throws up a roadblock to evolution. First off, even if evolution is true, it doesn't disprove God. Secondly, if someone believes that something is true, why would you fear any "threats"? It should be able to be tested. I mean, let's say that evolution could prove there is no God. Fine, then there is no God. Why would anyone want to believe in something that isn't real? You eventually tell your kids about the Easter bunny right? You break the bad news that Santa isn't real. Again, evolution does not disprove God, but if it could, then what's the point? Regardless, even if evolution is proved beyond the shadow of a doubt, you still have to account for the historical record of Christ. You still have to account for fulfilled prophecies. So the author of Genesis didn't lay out specifics, so what, if I'm writing a book about Henry Ford making a car, I'm not detailing every single component, I'm saying "Henry Ford made cars". It really all goes back to the initial point about fear. And I think the churches actions (what really matters) show a fear that they don't believe what they say they believe. If you take the bible to be God's infallible word, then eventually isn't the pursuing of evolution going to figure that out? Wouldn't it be wiser to let them take it to it's end of not being true (if your a strict bible person) so that people can come to belief? So I can see someone looking at the church and seeing the hypocrisy and saying "God is a hypocrite, no thanks". But I don't think they are looking at God, rather, they are looking at the God that churches have set up out of fear. And as Hobbes points out, fear does not produce God, fear simply creates religion.
I see the church of today in the same light. I know actually reading the bible is cliche these days, but you have Christ wrapping up every single law that was ever handed to the Jews with "Do unto others as you would expect them to do unto you". That was it, seems basic enough, common sense if you will. But these days, it's not good enough. If it were, you would have no need for a church. You would have no need for all the things that are "expected" of a good christian. Jesus words weren't good enough, we need laws that tell us how to act. Again, as if laws could save us.
I have to agree and disagree to the fear point though. Obviously I believe fear leads to religion, but I would disagree that fear leads to the belief in a higher power. Common sense says to me that there is a God. I'll delve more into this later in this response, but I have never seen something appear from nothing. History also says to me there is a God. The bible is just not a spiritual book, but it is also a history book. Events that are spelled out in it can be verified through various studies that we would accept for other historical events, I can take it as valid historically. Does it have holes? Sure. Do they effect the overall story being told by many different people over a long period of time? Not really. Read enough history books about any given event, or any other person and you will see disagreements here and disagreements there, but at the end of the day, you don't write any of them off because they disagreed over a name of a town or the number of people at a event. To use a current example, there will be thousands of books written about Barack Obama. I think there will be contradictions here and there, but I bet if we could go into the future, and read them all, we would end up saying, "eh, yea, you got some stuff off here and there, but the general consensus of all these books is an accurate portrait of who he was." I feel a meandering ramble coming on, so I am going to stop there. My basic point is there is no fear in either of those reasoning's and most would use both of those to come to a belief that would be considered "well thought out". (Side note: Oddly enough, it is my belief in the historical records of that book that makes me identical to you. Forgive me if I am reading this wrong, but it sounds like you just said a life without fear leads to "do unto others as you would expect them to do to you". And I couldn't agree more.)
As to the last point, I have to agree. Again, though, from a different perspective. I do not understand why the church throws up a roadblock to evolution. First off, even if evolution is true, it doesn't disprove God. Secondly, if someone believes that something is true, why would you fear any "threats"? It should be able to be tested. I mean, let's say that evolution could prove there is no God. Fine, then there is no God. Why would anyone want to believe in something that isn't real? You eventually tell your kids about the Easter bunny right? You break the bad news that Santa isn't real. Again, evolution does not disprove God, but if it could, then what's the point? Regardless, even if evolution is proved beyond the shadow of a doubt, you still have to account for the historical record of Christ. You still have to account for fulfilled prophecies. So the author of Genesis didn't lay out specifics, so what, if I'm writing a book about Henry Ford making a car, I'm not detailing every single component, I'm saying "Henry Ford made cars". It really all goes back to the initial point about fear. And I think the churches actions (what really matters) show a fear that they don't believe what they say they believe. If you take the bible to be God's infallible word, then eventually isn't the pursuing of evolution going to figure that out? Wouldn't it be wiser to let them take it to it's end of not being true (if your a strict bible person) so that people can come to belief? So I can see someone looking at the church and seeing the hypocrisy and saying "God is a hypocrite, no thanks". But I don't think they are looking at God, rather, they are looking at the God that churches have set up out of fear. And as Hobbes points out, fear does not produce God, fear simply creates religion.
Brad
Church does not equal god. Common sense laws should be enough, but sadly some want every aspect of life controlled so we are all the same (according to which holy book the person asking for the laws follows). If someone is going to be a person of god/jesus, his teaching should be enough and shouldn't ask for government to try and make every law match their particular interpretation of their given holy book. Yes, I was saying a life without fear comes back to common sense "do unto others....".
Now as far as the common sense says there is a god; clearly I disagree or this would be a really boring "debate". :) The (christian) bible as history book, to a certain degree. When it comes to any holy book and claim of a higher power, they are disagreeing on more than just the name of a town and the number of people at an event - God made the world in six days vs big bang is a bigger chasm than the Obama reference. This is sometimes where the ability to discuss/debate existence can be enjoyable and enlightening; but sadly, most people start hurling insults. Big Bang and Six Day Creation cannot be proved beyond reasonable doubt. They are both theories, and both should be tested all the time. This point in history, there are going to be "breakthroughs" from both sides, but there is still more unknown/unprovable than there is provable. However, with the Internet the way it is now (anyone can post anything about anything at anytime without need for proof or sources) is making it hard to know if what you are reading that may bend towards one theory or the other, is even based in (testable, provable) fact. The problem I have with the common sense argument is that there are things that occur in life and the world that have no clear/reasonable explanation based on what we know about the physical world. So depending on what it is, people will say it is part of "God's Plan". To me, that is a cop-out; If something doesn't make sense, investigate. I think a lot of people of faith are comfortable with not knowing and clutching to a higher power. It is certainly more comfortable than looking into a situation and maybe finding out/learning something you don't like, because it is harder to ignore what you now see. If things are looked into, it may make it harder to continue to hold on to your unyielding beliefs. Yes, I will give you there are going to be people on both sides of the argument who won't give the other side any "points" for what they are able to prove. As far as common sense, to me the common sense questions to ask are: 1. If god created everything we see, where did god come from? 2. If god can just come from nothing, why can't everything else? However, those questions could be a blog unto themselves.
Lastly, the part about fear doesn't lead to a higher power - I think it depends on the person. I think people who are uncomfortable/scared with the thought of their own mortality, do tend to be people who believe in god. I think the more self-aware someone is, and the more comfortable someone is with searching out truth about the world and human life and being OK with finding an unclear/no answer at all, will tend to be less reliant on faith (even if they do have faith, it won't control or be as large of a part of their everyday life). The thing that always makes me feel strongly about fear/higher power idea - traumatic events. The number of people who consider themselves believers, may even go to church, seem to pray their loudest and most reverent during plane crashes, hostages situations, etc. Hell, there are people who would consider themselves non-spiritual who will start praying during these events - what else could be driving them to seek out god's help if not fear?
No comments:
Post a Comment